如何研读论文
稍微翻译了一下:
1)花5min看懂标题(一些定义可在前言中找),and在看正文之前,
a)设想如何做该实验(写成list),实验会有些什么数据,根据这些数据如何得到结论,从而可发现:
1. did you miss a critical point, or (this happens) did they?
2. Did they mislead you with their title?
记住:having a list that varies from the list of actual experiments done by the authors is perfectly OK.
b)如果看文献是为了解决自己的问题:
Skip/ignore anything that doesn’t answer your questions. Then, generate your list of experiments.
2)看摘要:
一般有目的,方法,结论三部分。注意:找到
a)how and why the experiments were performed. You can then tell how close your list is to theirs.
b)get a sense for the order in which experiments are going to be presented. Ignore everything else.
3)仔细阅读正文的结论部分
a) Let them tell you why they did the experiments, and what they think happened as a result. Assume everything they tell you is the absolute truth
b)compare your list with theirs:
Write down what differences there are, and note why you think the lists are different: are the authors leaving things out you’d like to see, or are they on a different track than you?
The key here is to fully understand their train of thought. If you can’t figure it out, write that down, too, specifying exactly where you fell off
the train. Then move on. From here on, focus on the material you understand from the Results, and ignore what you don’t understand.
c)仔细看图及图的说明
BE CRITICAL: Assume they are trying to pull a fast one on you.
Make sure that when they say something, the data actually show it.
d)问两个问题:(在“材料和方法”中寻找,别在M&M中耗时间)
1. what are the controls for that experiment?
2. How do you know that this result isn’t due to something else?
e)找出隐藏结论(一般是限于篇幅而未能发表)
Challenge yourself to find alternate explanations for the results:
1. what do you think they chose to omit?
2. Why did they omit it?
(在继续读下去之前,列一个阅读所得的list)
4)looking for a clear justification for why the authors chose to do their experiments.
What is the main question that they claim to be answering?
5)Compare the authors’ main question, their data, and their conclusions.
1. did they answer their question?
2. Did they do the right experiments to address their question?
3. If your list of experiments differs from theirs, is their line of experimentation better?
4. If you had to answer this research question, knowing all that you know now, how would you do it? Maybe borrow some of their experiments? Or do exactly what they did?
6) Read the discussion
The discussion should tell you why their work is important, and how it advances the field.
评价该文很重要的一点:文中是否预料到并很好的回答了你的问题
7)Project into the future.
如果是你,下一步能做什么?有什么可提高的?有什么缺陷要弥补?如何与下一步工作衔接?
8)回顾整体风格
1. What phrases do they use to introduce their ideas?
2. How are the figures labeled?
3. Is this a well-constructed paper?
4. Is there anything in the paper you'd like to emulate?
-
土木工程实习证明(通用3篇)
土木工程实习证明篇1兹有学校土木工程专业同学于年月日至年月日在我单位进行实习。实习期间,我单位指导其进行了相关业务知识学习和实际操作训练。同学已经具备相关的专业技能和业务知识。特此证明。(实习单位公章)年月日土木工程实习证明篇2兹有_________学校...
-
社团招新策划书模板(精选8篇)
社团招新策划书模板篇1一、活动背景户外运动协会是作为新兴社团,社团还没无形成必然的规模,并在其他的方面存在诸多的成绩。面临这些成绩,我们需求新的血液,需求一个时机展现本人。此时正逢重生报到,各个社团招新在即。一年一度的招新活动行将开场。户外运动协会将...
-
公司早会口号(精选3篇)
公司早会口号篇11、努力为客户打造更给力的明天。2、细节决定成败,选择成就未来。3、劳动的时间与收获成正比4、如果没有今天,怎么会有未来。5、今日努力做事,明日高兴拿钱。6、凝聚我们的力量,收获明日的辉煌。7、如今拼搏于未来,未来享受于如今。8、同甘共苦创明...
-
社团辞职信(通用5篇)
社团辞职信篇1尊敬的各位领导:你们好!一提笔写这份报告,心里就有一种难以言喻的苦味,好像即将离开一个温暖的家一样。在写之前,我一直在思考自己是否真要的选择离开社联,这种选择近乎残忍,多少时候劝自己要留在社联,因为这里不但是一个锻炼自己能力的好地方,而且这里还...